2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

3rd place:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Victor Joecks
Columnist
Las Vegas Review-Journal
Las Vegas, Nevada

Third-place honors in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Victor Joecks, columnist with the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Third-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $750.

After a Review-Journal reporter exposed a county employee giving a lucrative contract to a firm connected with his wife’s company, the cover-up began. In these editorials, the Review-Journal called out county officials for hiding public records, showing the local community what questions the unreleased records could answer. A district court later ruled the county must turn over the requested records.

The Review-Journal’s strong editorial leadership demonstrated the newspaper’s unwavering commitment to fighting for transparency in government. It also showed other local officials that hiding public records would be a futile endeavor.

Two editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • I liked the succinctness of what was expressed.  It was powerful and didn’t waste any words.  No-frills, forceful writing.
  • I love an editorial that carries the fight to the evildoers and this was a really strong pair of editorials on an important subject.  If the Review-Journal had not published these editorials or raised these issues, who would have? Nobody!
  • It’s strongly written and it, apparently, had an impact.
  • At a time when governments, especially state governments, are pulling back with exemptions to public records laws and a lot of things are being hidden, this is such an important win for the First Amendment.  That in itself is a really powerful argument for why it deserves merit.
  • The writer makes a vigorous argument on behalf of a vitally important issue — conducting the government’s business in public.  

Read more about all contest winners