2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

2nd place:
Political/Social Commentary

Posted

Victor Joecks
Columnist
Las Vegas Review-Journal
Las Vegas, Nevada

Second-place honors in the Political/Social Commentary category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Victor Joecks, columnist with the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Second-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $1,250.

Nevada is a small state, which gives its biggest special interest groups outsized influence. It doesn’t happen often, but when the interests of big business, labor unions and the top leaders of both parties align, they don’t lose — until now.

In November 2025, Republican Gov. Joe Lombardo called a special legislative session, headlined by a proposal for transferable film tax credits. Those are de facto subsidies. Similar arrangements have created budget difficulties in other states. But whether from principle or their personal political interests, Lombardo and top legislative Democrats all supported it.

In these columns, Victor Joecks forcefully and fearlessly laid out why film tax credit programs are policy failures. His research and knowledge of Nevada’s economic development history showed the practical problems with this plan. His courageous stand against the state’s most powerful politicians and interest groups helped spearhead citizen outrage over this giveaway. In the end, the proposal failed — by a single vote. These columns helped save Nevada taxpayers around $1.5 billion over 15 years.

Three columns were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • All three columns were effective in what they were trying to put forth.  All three columns were solid and very well written.  They followed an arc from the first to the second to the third.  But all three also stood on their own.
  • The columns were well argued and had impact.  Ultimately, the proposal for the tax credits failed.  
  • Well-written, effective and a nice wrap-up (the third column) to this set of themed columns.

Read more about all contest winners