2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

1st place Editorials — over 35,000 circulation

Posted

Victor Joecks
Columnist
Las Vegas Review-Journal
Las Vegas, Nevada

Top honors in the over 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Victor Joecks, columnist with the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

First-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $2,250.

This entry was submitted by Sheila Morales of The  Review-Journal on behalf of Joecks.  On the entry form, she wrote: “For years, the Review-Journal editorial page fearlessly called out some of the most powerful local officials — Las Vegas City Council members — for flagrantly violating the property rights of a local developer. The editorial section warned how costly that move would be. Sure enough, the City of Las Vegas lost repeatedly in court. Urged on by the paper, the city council finally admitted defeat and moved forward a settlement agreement in December 2024. The final settlement, agreed to in March 2025, cost the city more than $250 million, but continuing to fight a losing battle would have exposed taxpayers to even greater liability.”

She said, “This demonstrates the power and importance of courageous, locally produced editorials. These entries highlighted an issue of deep importance to the community and spurred elected officials to action.”

Two editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • One judge commented: “These editorials capture the long-awaited ending of a series of negative decisions by the Las Vegas City Council over the long-running Badlands dispute. We liked the direct tone and bite of the editorials, which made very clear that the actions of Council members have frustrated taxpayers and the editorial board for much too long, at considerable expense.” She added: “The 2nd editorial's call for further accountability, even post-settlement, was also appreciated.”
  • Another judge also noted that the Review-Journal “has been banging the drum on this issue” for many years with a seemingly relentless pursuit of the issue. 
  • Judges cited the strong accountability angle, the direct language and the fact that the editorials didn't pull any punches.