Steve Stewart
Steve Stewart
Publisher
The Smithfield Times
Smithfield, Virginia
Third-place honors in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Columns category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Steve Stewart, publisher of The Smithfield Times.
Third-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $500.
In this collection of columns, Stewart chronicles a historic small town's battle against rapid residential growth, and accompanying political fallout.
Three columns were submitted as part of this entry:
Among the comments made by contest judges:
- Judges said these columns showed strong, accountable writing with meaningful commentary on local issues. They also said it demonstrated courage by holding local officials accountable in a smaller community context.
- One judge noted that she put a bunch of exclamation marks next to two words in the last paragraph in the column about the Town Council. She said she particularly loved the two words that she highlighted in this paragraph: “I’m asked often whether the small group of elected and unelected people who run Smithfield are corrupt. They’re not, in my opinion. But they operate with a degree of paternalistic condescension unlike anything I’ve witnessed in four decades of reporting on small-town politics. They know what’s best for the town, and the peasants just need to shut up and pay their taxes.”
- Another comment from that same judge: “It can be difficult to really hold local officials accountable when you're in a smaller area and doing it with the courage that he does here is commendable. One of the things that this contest is designed to recognize is the courage that it took to write particular columns or editorials.”
- Judges said columnists don't have to get nasty in expressing their opinions, which is one of the things that they liked about Stewart's entries. As one judge said: “I loved that it was just facts upon facts upon facts ... instead of ‘I feel this’ or ‘I feel that.’ So, I really enjoyed these columns.”