2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

3rd place Editorials — over 35,000 circulation

Posted

Nick Hrkman
Community Impact Editor
Dayton Daily News
Dayton, Ohio

Third-place honors in the over 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Nick Hrkman, community impact editor  of the Dayton Daily News in Ohio. He was honored for a singular editorial arguing that then-Vice Presidential candidate and Senator JD Vance's behavior is unbecoming of his office. 

Third-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $500.

The intentional spread of misinformation about Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, during the week of the presidential debate thrust a vulnerable community into the national spotlight. 

Hrkman said: “The hideous, debunked rumor about Haitians in Springfield eating pets was amplified by both then-candidates JD Vance and Donald Trump, causing a series of disruptive bomb threats to schools and government offices in the city. Over the course of that week, our editorial board responded quickly with an initial editorial about the dangers of misinformation, and then a more forceful editorial condemning statements made by JD Vance following the initial outburst.”

He  submitted for consideration the paper's second editorial about JD Vance, which “we feel was especially warranted given his connection to our region — Middletown, in our coverage area, is his hometown — and his powerful position as both U.S. senator and vice presidential candidate.”

Read the editorial:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • One judge summed up the judges' thoughts, saying: “Well-written and emphatic, this editorial rightly took JD Vance to task for his reckless disregard for truth and for knowingly spreading falsehoods — which resulted in direct dire consequences. We would've liked to have seen at least one more editorial  by this writer/on this theme.”
  • Another judge added: “I thought it was powerful writing, direct and specific.  It had both local and national impact. ... I also liked that he just called it a lie. He just came out and said it.  He didn't waffle around.  I liked the line: ‘Senator, Ohioans need your help, not your hate.’”