Silver Solutions Partner

Publication of private facts: Guidelines for reporting on sensitive topics

Posted

It is often said that truth is a complete defense to a defamation claim. Unfortunately, that principle does not apply to invasion of privacy torts, including “publication of private facts.” This claim, recognized in the vast majority of states, is actionable where a speaker or writer conveys a private fact about someone, and the disclosure would be highly offensive to a reasonable person. The risk of a private facts claim often arises in reporting on a sensitive or intimate topic — like a person’s health, finances, sexual history or orientation, or family history (e.g., fertility, adoptive status) — especially if the subject of the reporting is not a prominent figure.

That said, the law places important limitations on publication of private facts claims. Most notably, there can be no liability where the information was already public or is newsworthy. In addition, journalists and publishers can take certain steps to reduce risk when reporting on a sensitive subject. This is a guide to help explain the nature of the risks and how best to mitigate them.

The elements of the tort

A publication of private facts claim has several elements: the defendant must (i) disclose or publish (ii) a fact about someone that is private, and (iii) the disclosure must be highly offensive to a reasonable person.

The first and second elements are straightforward, but the third is somewhat less intuitive. The disclosure of a private fact will not be actionable unless “highly offensive” to a reasonable reader or viewer. There is no exhaustive list of “highly offensive” disclosures, and the law differs from state to state. But in practice, the disclosure must be about an aspect of a person’s life that society regards as sensitive or intimate. Disclosures that would cause genuine embarrassment or stigma may also qualify. Disclosures commonly regarded as highly offensive include those about a person’s medical conditions or treatment, sexual orientation, sexual history, financial status, and family matters like fertility, paternity, and adoptive status. The disclosure of sensitive images (like autopsy or death scene photos, photos of a private funeral or intimate personal photos) or sensitive communications (like private text messages) may also be treated as highly offensive. You should take special care when reporting on sensitive topics such as these.

But even if all three of the elements exist, a speaker or publisher will not be liable if the information is already public or is legitimately within the public interest.

Is the information already public?

Because a claim for the disclosure of private facts must be predicated on disclosure of a “private” fact, information that is already public is not actionable, even if you gave it further publicity.

In some cases, the information at issue is obviously public. For instance, publishing information that comes from a public record, like a police report or court filing, is generally not actionable. (That may not be true if the filing was sealed.) Publishing information obtained at an event open to the public would likewise be lawful. In one notable example, a federal appeals court rejected a private facts claim based on the publication of photos from a soldier’s funeral (including a photo of the deceased soldier) given that the funeral was open casket, open to the public and attended by 1,200 people.

In other cases, though, plaintiffs may argue that the information was not sufficiently public to preclude liability, even though they had shared it with a limited group of people. This argument is often made in cases where the prior disclosure was made online, including, for example to their friends or followers on social media. To determine whether such a disclosure counts as “public,” courts will generally examine the context. A person who shares a fact widely and without restriction (e.g., by posting on their public Instagram account) cannot have a reasonable expectation of privacy in it. But the same is not necessarily true where the plaintiff discloses the fact to a smaller, discrete audience — for instance, where the disclosure was made to a Facebook group whose members were “expected to follow strict privacy rules as a condition” of joining the group. (In that real-life case, the court allowed the claim to go to trial.)

At bottom, the question is: given the circumstances of the prior disclosures, did the plaintiff have a reasonable expectation of privacy?

Is the information newsworthy?

Often the most important legal issue in a private facts case is whether the information was newsworthy or otherwise bore on a matter of public concern. In that analysis, courts typically consider whether the information concerns a recent event or a prominent figure, or is otherwise logically connected to the exploration of social issues or public affairs. Put more simply, the courts will ask whether the published information has public or social value, or is simply salacious and prurient. 

A key point here is that it is generally not enough that the information relates to an event or issue that is newsworthy; the information itself must also be of public concern. The courts often make that distinction in ruling against publishers. An illustrative example is a lawsuit brought by the mother of Nancy Benoit against the publisher of Hustler Magazine in 2008. The magazine published an article about Benoit, who had been murdered by her husband (former professional wrestler Chris Benoit), that included decades-old nude images of Benoit from her modeling days. A federal appeals court reinstated the mother’s privacy claim after the lower court dismissed it, finding that while the article related to a newsworthy subject (Ms. Benoit’s murder), the photos had no relationship to that. In another famous example, a Florida jury ordered the publication Gawker to pay $140 million to the wrestler Hulk Hogan after it published excerpts of a sex tape featuring Hogan and his best friend’s wife. While the fact of the affair may have been newsworthy given Hogan’s prominence, the images themselves were not.

Even if your reporting is less prurient, you should consider newsworthiness at a specific level, not a general one. An alleged rape may be newsworthy, but the victim’s name may not be. The risks of low-cost cosmetic surgery in Costa Rica may be of public concern, but the identity of a person who received a botched facelift may not be. (Yes, that one is a real case.)

How can I reduce risk?

The legal risks depend greatly on the circumstances of a specific case — the nature of the information at issue, how it will be presented to the audience, the litigiousness of the subject of your reporting, and the law of the relevant state, among others — and it may be wise to seek the assistance of legal counsel.

Generally, though, there are basic steps you can take to reduce risk:

  • Seek consent. Consent is a complete defense to a private facts claim. Often it is difficult to convince a person to agree to the publication of private facts about them. But if you are able to do it, consider memorializing the agreement in writing in case you need to rely on it later.
  • Render the individual at issue unidentifiable. There is no invasion of privacy if the plaintiff cannot be reasonably identified. So consider whether you can render the subject of your reporting unidentifiable, whether through visual effects (like blurring) or by keeping their name and identifying details out of the story. Make sure to obscure anything that could reasonably identify the person.
  • Highlight the public interest in the information. If the newsworthiness of the information may not be obvious to the reader, consider explicitly highlighting it in your story. Explain why it was important to publish graphic images or private text messages. The transparency serves your readers and will bolster your newsworthiness argument if you find yourself in court.

A final note: the above guidelines are based on law in the United States. If you are writing about individuals abroad, especially in Europe, it may be prudent to consult international counsel. Privacy laws vary by country just as they do by state, and European countries in particular tend to be much more protective of individual privacy.

To connect with Mutual Insurance Company, contact:

Sinead Murphy
Managing Director
MiC Specialty
sinead@micspecialty.com