Byron Tate
Editor
The Pine Bluff Commercial
Pine Bluff, Arkansas
Second-place honors in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Byron Tate, editor of The Pine Bluff Commercial in Arkansas.
Second-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $1,000.
The power structure in Pine Bluff had all the cards: a sales tax with the proceeds going to their cherished projects, a sympathetic mayor and city council and even a stacked deck with several city commissions that handled matters to their liking.
“But,” Tate said, “it all has come to mostly naught. Downtown buildings and property that cost millions sit empty — just as they did before the city's urban renewal agency bought them. The cost of new projects continues to soar but are years behind schedule. Investors run for the exits after bait-and-switch promises are made and broken. And if anyone on the city's payroll gets in their way, suddenly they are fired for having the audacity to make a stand.”
In submitting his entry for the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize, Tate said: “This has been going on for seven years now, but the promises and failures are just now coming into view, what with the completion dates for projects always another season away. ‘It'll be finished in spring’ has become an unfortunate laugh line for a multi-million dollar tax effort that has largely gone nowhere. In the end, the mayor was voted out of office, and the extension of the sales tax went down in flames not once but twice as they tried to extend the charade. So finally, those in charge aren't so much and the city has a chance to make real changes to the good.”
Tate said: “It's has been a privilege for me to write editorials on the topics because they were issues that the public had to be made aware of. And in the end, the public left the bad stuff behind.”
Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:
Among the comments made by contest judges: