2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

1st place Columns — under 35,000 circulation

Posted

Blake Fontenay
Columnist
TC Palm / Treasure Coast Newspapers
Fort Pierce, Florida

Top honors in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Columns category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Blake Fontenay, columnist with TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers.  Fontenay has since been named commentary editor with USA TODAY.

First-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $2,250.

Adam Neal, executive editor of TCPalm, submitted this entry on behalf of Fontenay. Neal said Fontenay “showed bravery and tenacity throughout 2024 while investigating the questionable appointment of a Florida sheriff.”

He said: “Fontenay faced several dilemmas as he boldly pursued the truth around why Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis appointed a mid-level sheriff’s employee to lead the department following the abrupt resignation of the longtime sheriff.

“Late in 2023, longtime St. Lucie County Sheriff Ken Mascara unexpectedly resigned, citing unspecified health reasons. This resignation followed an earlier Florida Department of Law Enforcement investigation into Mascara and others, including Lt. Keith Pearson, around a ‘straw’ or ‘ghost’ candidate. FDLE concluded Mascara actively recruited a ghost candidate, but the state attorney DeSantis assigned to the case declined to file charges. DeSantis, on the same day Mascara resigned, passed up higher ranking sheriff’s employees to appoint Pearson to lead the department.”

Neal said: “TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers launched an investigation around the appointment, spearheaded by Fontenay. Several insiders told Fontenay not to pursue the story. As he courted sources inside and outside the sheriff’s office, Fontenay was told by deputies the new sheriff openly discussed plots to discredit him and other journalists such as by surveilling and conducting phony DUI traffic stops on them.”

“These intimidation attempts didn’t stop Fontenay,” Neal said. “He questioned DeSantis, Pearson and others about the appointment — without response — filed multiple public records requests — also without response — and relied on shoe leather reporting and deep sourcing to learn about a quiet, central figure: local businessman Tony DiFrancesco. His investigation found DiFrancesco is a convicted felon who DeSantis pardoned in early 2023. Two weeks before the surprise resignation and appointment, DiFrancesco — a major Pearson supporter and donor  — hosted a private fundraiser for DeSantis’ then-active presidential campaign that helped secure hundreds of thousands of dollars in contributions.”

“Hearing threats of litigation if the news organization published this information,” Neal said Fontenay and his editors “concluded the information was too important for the community not to know — especially as Pearson launched an election campaign for sheriff. They discussed the relevance of DiFrancesco’s lengthy criminal record, which was several decades old, and the overall importance to the story. They agreed the record was relevant and published the details.”

He said: “A key component verifying the private fundraiser was a photo of DeSantis, Pearson and DiFrancesco together, provided by a source. Journalists agreed to protect the source’s identity — something those involved in the fundraiser and with Pearson pushed us to release after the initial column published. Following the column, Pearson blacklisted TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers from media releases, press conferences and public records fulfillment. After a lot of discussion and exhaustion of all other possibilities, TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers hired an attorney and filed a formal intent to sue Pearson and the Sheriff’s Office.”

DiFrancesco filed a defamation lawsuit against Fontenay, TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers and others. He later withdrew Fontenay and TCPalm / Treasure Coast Newspapers from the suit after the newspaper’s attorneys responded. Neal said a judge eventually dismissed everything with prejudice.

He said: “The impact of Fontenay’s reporting led to challenger Richard Del Toro defeating Pearson, an early favorite for being elected sheriff because DeSantis appointed him months prior, in the election.”

Three columns were submitted as part of this entry, all of which can be viewed at this link:

  • No shocker: Records show DeSantis' staff planned Keith Pearson's appointment well in advance
  • 'Swamp' fever: Sheriff Pearson's letter to St. Lucie residents suggests he's cracking
  • St. Lucie Sheriff Keith Pearson tried to fool voters from the very start. They noticed.

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • They cited Fontenay's tenacity in going after the sheriff, calling this really good accountability journalism.  They were impressed with the way he stayed on it when he was under pressure to let it go ... and he got results.  “This was outstanding work,” they said.