2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

2nd place Editorials — over 35,000 circulation

Posted

Arnessa Garrett
Deputy Editor | Opinion
The Times-Picayune | The Advocate
Louisiana

Second-place honors in the over 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Arnessa Garrett, deputy editor | opinion of The Times-Picayune | The Advocate in Louisiana, for editorials about vaccines and public health.

Second-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $1,000.

“Our editorial board has consistently championed public health and the promotion of the safety and efficacy of vaccines,” Garrett said.  “In Louisiana as in many places around the county, we are seeing more vaccine hesitancy, and that is having real consequences for our children. At the same time, mixed messages from some of our statewide elected officials are contributing to confusion among the public. In January, we sharply criticized the Louisiana surgeon general’s efforts to de-emphasize vaccination efforts at state health clinics and asked whether officials were abdicating their duty to provide clear guidelines to follow. In February, we outlined the scope of the risk that Louisiana is facing. We also pointed out that the Senate confirmation of noted vaccine skeptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as Secretary of Health and Human Services, largely thanks to Louisiana Sen. Bill Cassidy, amplified the problem on the federal level.”

“By May, when a measles outbreak hit our neighboring state of Texas, perhaps public health officials got the message as they were quick to issue a statement that the measles vaccine is safe,” Garrett said.  “While we won’t say that our efforts prompted a complete overhaul of vaccine policy in the state, we are pleased to see increased activism in the arena of public health and more lawmakers who are willing to listen.”

Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • One judge commented: “Given today's growing vaccine skepticism, which runs counter to good public health, these editorials are important for underscoring the imperative for immunizations. Speaking up firmly and eloquently on the need for vaccinations, especially when community health leaders fail to do so, is underscored by these editorials.”
  • Another judge said: “In the courage realm ... on the one hand, it doesn't take a lot of bravery to say vaccines are a good thing.” But, in this era right now, he added, there's a lot of pushback against that view.