2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Isabella Loy, assistant editor
Rebecca Poynter, publisher
Dan Ruthemeyer, managing editor

Stanwood Camano News
Stanwood, Washington

Isabella Loy, Rebecca Poynter and Dan Ruthemeyer of the Stanwood Camano News are additional finalists in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

The Stanwood Camano News formed its editorial board to address a public records issue involving the Stanwood-Camano School Board.

The editorial argues that the Stanwood-Camano School Board is undermining public trust by using personal email accounts to conduct school district business. The newspaper discovered the practice while seeking records related to the investigation and leave of Utsalady Elementary Principal Michael Hanna. Although the district provided emails from official accounts, it has refused to release communications from board members’ personal accounts.

The editorial says Washington’s Public Records Act applies to public-agency records regardless of where they are stored. It acknowledges there may be nothing improper in the private emails but argues the public cannot know that without seeing them. The newspaper has filed a lawsuit seeking their release, saying transparency is necessary to uphold public trust and freedom-of-information laws.

The entry form noted: “We wanted to explain to readers why we felt we had no choice but to file a lawsuit against the Stanwood-Camano School District. We have since dealt with subpoening board members, obtaining thousands of withheld records, and are currently in the process of working out a settlement agreement with the district. This editorial garnered much attention from the community and encouraged board members to comply with public records laws.”

One editorial was submitted with this entry:

Contest judges said:

  • Challenging school boards and public institutions isn’t an easy thing to do.  You’re taking on a public body that has a lot more resources than you do. This was a brave editorial from a small newspaper.  It’s a small newspaper doing what it should be doing and it deserves a nod from the judges.  

Read more about all contest winners