2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Julieta Chiquillo, Jennifer Nagorka and Rudy Bush
Members of The Dallas Morning News Editorial Board
The Dallas Morning News
Dallas, Texas

Julieta Chiquillo, Jennifer Nagorka and Rudy Bush, members of the Editorial Board of The Dallas Morning News, are additional finalists in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

Their entry focused on the future of Fair Park.

Fair Park is Dallas’ most treasured historical asset, a 277-acre art deco park complex where Texas celebrated its centennial in 1936 and where the State Fair of Texas sets up camp every fall. After letting the grounds and infrastructure decay for years, the city of Dallas turned over management to a newly formed nonprofit and a big-name venue operator in 2018, hoping to revive the park.

In submitting this entry, Julieta Chiquillo wrote: “That plan blew up in 2025, with the park left even worse off than it was when the deal was signed seven years earlier. The Editorial Board deconstructed the public-private partnership, down to the last days of the contentious arrangement, to give readers the most detailed public account of how the deal went sideways. We also laid out a series of deeply reported recommendations to light a path forward for saving Fair Park.”

She said: “Our series encouraged the city and its parks department not to abandon the idea of privatization, but to approach it differently, and with stronger oversight. The city previously had a single master contract with the nonprofit, which delegated its duties to the for-profit venue operator. Now the department is maintaining direct control over the fairgrounds and oversees a few specialized contracts, such as for marketing and event booking.”

She added: “After our series ran, we noticed an intense scrutiny of the nonprofit partner in public meetings, and we’ve heard from city leaders that they are studying ideas for another public-private partnership in the future.” 

Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

One contest judge commented:

  • What I loved about these editorials was the narrative.  It took you on a story that was riveting.  Sometimes editorial writing can be very stale. This was something that brought you into the story about a very local issue involving public space.  Not only was it great writing, but solutions were offered.  And, now there’s some action that is slowly coming together.

Read more about all contest winners