2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Amelia Robinson
Opinion and Community Engagement Editor
The Columbus Dispatch
Columbus, Ohio

Amelia Robinson, opinion and community engagement editor of The Columbus Dispatch, is an additional finalist in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

Her entry focused on a scandal that forced the resignation of the Ohio State University president.

In March 2026, Ted Carter resigned as president of Ohio State University, one of the largest universities in the nation and one of the largest employers in Columbus, Ohio.

In submitting this entry on behalf of Robinson, Ohio Bureau Chief Anthony Shoemaker, wrote:  “The university quickly tried to move on from the scandal by choosing the university provost as the new president. There was no public input, no meetings with students or faculty. The editorial board of The Columbus Dispatch called the university out for its lack of transparency. Opinion editor Amelia Robinson penned the editorials that called for OSU to do a thorough investigation into the scandal.”

Two editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • When you look at public records and transparency, I thought this was particularly powerful because you have the newspaper taking on a behemoth in Ohio — Ohio State University and its secretive process of replacing the president. The two editorials complemented each other.  First, they framed the issue ... really helping the public understand why this was wrong.  And then secondly, calling into question the criminal aspects of it and the potential that OSU could be in violation of the law.
  • Clearly, the university would rather that the newspaper not pay attention to the event that unfolded here.  They would rather have the people of Ohio ignore their decisions and get on with their lives.  By just bringing this to the public’s attention, that’s a huge service to the people of Ohio. Secondly, I thought it was well framed and understandable,  the two editorials together are bookends — the beginning of the case and a strong recommendation on what should happen now.  I just thought the editorials were very well-written and vitally important.
  • This goes to show that at a time when institutions are bullying journalism, the newspaper fought back.  And, while there wasn’t a result yet, we know that it sometimes takes a long time to see a result.  But, I think these editorials started a very important conversation about abuses and the lack of transparency at OSU. I think it took a lot of courage to do that.
  • I think it’s harder to call out public education or higher education compared to city government or county government these days.  And, it seems like they put a lot of work and research into these editorials, which clearly explained what the issue was and why it’s a concern for the public.

Read more about all contest winners