2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Arnessa Garrett
Opinion Page Editor
The Times-Picayune | The Advocate
Louisiana

Arnessa Garrett, opinion page editor of The Times-Picayune | The Advocate, is an additional finalist in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

Her entry focused on voting rights in Louisiana.

In submitting her entry, she wrote: “The massive changes to how we vote in Louisiana over the course of a year has had a string of predictable consequences, including lower turnout and voter confusion. First came the switch to closed party primaries after the state for decades had an open primary system. On top of that, there was an aggressive effort by the Secretary of State’s office to remove inactive voters from the rolls. Then, the state Legislature eliminated the position of the duly elected Clerk of Criminal Court in New Orleans, sparking widespread outrage. And lastly, the Supreme Court handed down a ruling in the landmark case Louisiana v. Callais involving Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, which led to a hasty redrawing of the state’s congressional district map and the cancellation of state’s elections for U.S. House seats.”

She said: “Throughout the year, our editorial board has advocated for greater voter education and condemned the rush to upend voting rules. We argued that fairness and transparency in the election process is a value to all. But in the weeks leading up to our May 16 primary, we focused our efforts. And after it was over, we pointed out how voter confusion leads to unintended consequences, as local tax renewals and constitutional amendments also on the ballot went down amid a wave of voter outrage.”

She said: “While politicians continued to push forward despite our warnings, we nevertheless, are beginning to see the first stirrings of voter organization and citizen activism, including what is turning out to be an unexpectedly strong campaign to recall the governor and the attorney general who have led this charge. We also saw the New Orleans City Council stand up to state officials and defend the rights of voters. We believe that through our words, we gave courage to those who seek to strengthen our democratic process.”

Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • I thought the importance of the topic was so powerful.  The message — go vote, even when institutions try to mess with the process — should be stated in every jurisdiction where the news is serving the citizenry.  I thought these editorials did a very good job of making that point.
  • I liked the powerful message these editorials made: They can try to engineer the outcome, but they can’t make it happen unless you don’t go vote!  Judges said that message was most powerful in the first editorial listed above.  That editorial states, in part:

    “With this ruling, we must renew our commitment as voters. If politicians are certain that they can determine who holds power by slicing and dicing the electorate and pitting groups against one another, we still have the power to prove them wrong. By doing so, we honor those who marched and fought and died for equal access to the ballot box.”

Read more about all contest winners