2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist - Editorials

Posted

Jeff Kovaleski, Editorial Writer, and
Fred McKissack, Editorial Page Editor
The Journal Gazette
Fort Wayne, Indiana

Jeff Kovaleski, editorial writer, and Fred McKissack, editorial page editor at The Journal Gazette in Fort Wayne, Indiana, are additional finalists in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

The three editorials that Lisa Green, managing editor, entered on their behalf focused on questionable choices made by Indiana's elected officials.

She said: “Indiana politics give writers — whether on the news side and most certainly on the opinion side — plenty of content. From no-bid contracts and favoritism, to lavish spending on vehicles and perpetuating unnecessary and illegitimate claims about potential voter fraud, some of our state leaders — particularly our secretary of state Diego Morales — are prime examples of being out of touch with far too many voters, people they have been elected to represent.”

“While Indiana is solidly a ‘red’ state, our editorial board team prefers to always safely land on the side of common sense, what's right — ethically and fiscally, be it for the short term or long term,” Green said. “That said, our chief editorial writer Jeff Kovaleski and editorial page editor, have shown a skill for shaping the voice of our entire editorial board into researched and reasoned criticism when it's called for. The three editorials submitted are just a few examples to prove that, and certainly worthy of an award.”

Their entry included these three editorials:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • Judges called the editorials very informative, saying: “This is the kind of thing that is just the quintessential role of newspapers and good local community reporting  ... the watchdog aspect that is serving the public particularly well.”
  • Another judge said this entry was strong and well documented, calling it a “strong example of a state-level watch with clear implications for local readers.”