2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist - Editorials

Posted

Dave Coffey
Editorial Page Editor
The Berkshire Eagle
Pittsfield, Massachusetts

Dave Coffey, editorial page editor of The Berkshire Eagle, is an additional finalist in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

After a sexual misconduct scandal emerged at an all-girls private school in the heart of the Berkshires, The Eagle editorial board joined a chorus of principled voices in the affected community calling for a long overdue modern update to the state’s outdated age-of-consent law.

Coffey said: “In Massachusetts, the legal age of sexual consent is 16 years, with no carveouts regarding problematic relationships between minors and adults in authoritative positions. That means several alumnae of this private school who have accused a former teacher of grooming and sexually abusing them over the course of years will not be able to see justice done in a Massachusetts court of law.”

Coffey said: “Our editorials channeled the community outrage stemming from this scandal into a call for a common sense legislative solution, resulting in legislation filed in the Statehouse that would close this so-called ‘age-of-consent loophole.’”

Coffey's entry included these two editorials:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • One judge commented on the fact that Coffey used the Freedom of Information Act to get a lot of information for these editorials, which he said was very important.
  • Another judge said that — based on thoughtfulness, courage, constructiveness and local relevance — this entry was among the top entries: a “locally impactful editorial series that underscored the newspaper's commitment to investigative reporting and accountability.”