2025 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

Additional Finalist - Columns

Posted

Greg Weatherbee
Publisher
The Lufkin Daily News
Lufkin, Texas

Greg Weatherbee, publisher of The Lufkin Daily News in Texas, is an additional finalist in the under 35,000 circulation category of the Columns category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition.

Josh Havard, editor of The Lufkin Daily News, submitted this entry on behalf of Weatherbee.  The columns included in the entry  broached topics that go from a personal level all the way to one on a national stage.

Havard said: “His column on mental health talked about his own firsthand experiences with the topic and how it was necessary for him to get the help he needed. People reached out through social media as well as email to thank him for sharing his personal matter. Some shared their own experiences, which will hopefully inspire others to seek help for themselves.”

His column about the community getting to decide if the newspaper is worth saving took a different approach than the general one of telling people to subscribe with no background of why they should. “Of course, we got some of the usual expected feedback of telling us we weren't worth saving,” Havard said. “But the general sentiment was positive while also giving us things we could improve or add to our paper.”

The final topic on the aftermath of the election was what Havard felt was a necessary one. He said: “We're in a heavy-Trump area and the general reaction was one of gloating. He put the perspective, once again on a personal level, that we should be mindful of everyone in the process. While I know nothing will change many people's minds, it did lend a voice to the minority of people who were fearful of the results.”

His entry included three columns:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • The third column above talked about the fears expressed (following the presidential election) by Weatherbee's son, Ethan, who is transitioning to become his daughter, Elise. Judges noted the courage it takes to put your children's lives out there in public — whether it's in a fun, pleasant poking fun sort of way or something more serious.  
  • They also commended Weatherbee for the courage it took to write about his own mental health challenges in the first column.
  • Judges said Weatherbee does an excellent job of communicating his point in a way that hooks readers.
  • They also cited the courage it took to write about the newspaper, saying a community should decide if a newspaper is worth saving.  “You have to be confident that you can make the case for the industry” to do this, they said.