2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

3rd place:
Political/Social Commentary

Posted

Leah Binkovitz
Senior Editorial Writer
Houston Chronicle
Houston, Texas

Third-place honors in the Political/Social Commentary category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Leah Binkovitz, senior editorial writer with the Houston Chronicle.

Third-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $750.

This series of columns tackled the aftermath of the deadly July 4th Texas Hill Country floods through the people left to do the hardest work: volunteers searching riverbanks and treetops for bodies, neighbors organizing their own rescues and recovery hubs, and Houston families mourning children lost at Camp Mystic.

Evan Mintz, editor of opinion and community engagement for the Houston Chronicle, who submitted the entry packet on behalf of Binkovitz, wrote: “Rather than treating the disaster as a one-time act of nature, the columns exposed a deeper civic failure: the gap between Texans’ extraordinary willingness to help one another and the inability of government systems to reach, warn, rescue and support them fast enough.”

He said these columns contributed to a wider movement for systemic reforms at the state level, including new regulations for summer camps, and greater scrutiny on FEMA, which eventually led to the resignation of the head of FEMA and the resignation of the secretary of homeland security.

Three columns were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • She wrote about the Texas Hill Country floods in a very compelling way. It was newsy and she was passionate in her personal feelings, which she brought into the columns. 
  • She is a very eloquent writer and I considered this to be one of the two that really were the class of the contest.  The writing was really excellent.  
  • Her writing was very poignant, very personal.  It was refreshing to see an opinion writer doing on the ground reporting and making it come through the way she did.

Read more about all contest winners