2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

2nd place:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Lori Falce
Community Engagement Editor
TribLive/Tribune-Review
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Second-place honors in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Lori Falce, community engagement editor of TribLive/Tribune-Review.

Second-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $1,250.

These editorials examined failures in Pennsylvania's child welfare system through the deaths of Renesmay Eutsey and Bella Seachrist and the lack of independent oversight meant to protect vulnerable children.  Together, they trace how gaps in accountability allow abuse to go unseen and argue for structural changes to prevent future tragedies.

The newspapers used the editorials to urge lawmakers and Gov. Josh Shapiro to establish an Office of Child Advocate, writing: “The idea is not new. It isn’t even hard. It just isn’t done. Advocates say the office would provide something the current system lacks — an objective layer of oversight for a child welfare structure that largely reviews itself.”

Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • The topic itself is just such a heartstring tugger.  
  • I kept coming back to these editorials and thinking about them the next day and the next couple of days.  It’s so hard to keep people’s attention these days.  And, the fact that these editorials resonated that much speaks volumes to the work and the research that she put into it.  It was a powerful entry.
  • The way she wove these two cases together ... they happened during different time frames and not in exactly the same place.  People might not have been aware of both of them. I really felt like nobody else would have woven these two stories together if she hadn't written these editorials the way she did.
  • This series of editorials offered a strong presentation of a heartbreaking subject matter, and the editorials made me want to learn more.  
  • Another judge cited the editorials’ potential to prompt community action on a difficult topic.  

Read more about all contest winners