2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

1st place:
Political/Social Commentary

Posted

Bridget Grumet
Editorial Page Editor
Austin American-Statesman
Austin, Texas

Top honors in the Political/Social Commentary category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Bridget Grumet, editorial page editor of the Austin American-Statesman.

First-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $3,000.

A letter by Josh Brodesky, director of opinion at the Austin American-Statesman, summarized Grumet’s entry, saying: “Sometimes Austin police break down doors or gates while chasing suspects or responding to 911 calls. Sometimes innocent bystanders or vulnerable residents are left with the damage: splintered doors that won’t lock, repair bills that some people can’t afford.

“The city never pays for it.

“In her three-part column series ‘Damaged for Good,’ Austin American-Statesman Editorial Page Editor Bridget Grumet examined this hidden consequence of a public safety response that leaves residents less secure. Drawing on hundreds of pages of claims requests and police reports, as well as interviews with residents, police officials, attorneys and advocates, Bridget found that Austin denied all 135 claims for police-related damages to buildings over a six-year period — including cases involving welfare checks, medical emergencies, domestic violence calls and a handful of wrong doors.

“Importantly, Bridget showed this is not a niche issue. The damages in most of these cases — small enough for City Hall to ignore yet large enough to destabilize some households — raise larger questions about who bears the cost of emergency response and whether the city’s public safety mission ends when the police leave the scene.

“Bridget’s deeply reported, community-based opinion writing highlights harm, gives voice to those who have been overlooked and challenges the City Council to realign its policies to match the city’s values.”

Impact of the columns: In a subsequent email about the impact of the columns, Grumet wrote: “The City of Austin unveiled a new process for reviewing the types of property damage claims I wrote about — in a significant reversal, they will start paying when property is damaged and it wasn’t the resident’s fault. Previously, the city refused to pay for anything.”

Three columns were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • Grumet’s columns were well argued without being hyperbolic.  I thought she made great use of anecdotes.  It was just tremendously convincing.  No matter what your political perspectives are, it would be hard to read these arguments and not come away convinced and in agreement.  It was powerful.  
  • It’s good reporting with data, but with real voices and it resonates.  I’ll remember these.  It’s very conversational with good narrative, but opinion is interjected throughout the columns.  
  • We live in an age where there is so much polarization and partisanship.  There’s nothing wrong with opinion pieces that are partisan and she’s writing from a state (Texas) where there’s quite a bit of partisanship.  But, I don’t know anybody who could read her columns — whether you’re left, right or in the middle — and not have been convinced of the power of her arguments.  
  • Well-written, engaging and useful.  Deeply reported with real people as examples and a possible solution built in.

Read more about all contest winners