2026 Carmage Walls Commentary Prize

1st place:
Focused Editorials

Posted

Inez Russell Gomez
Opinion Page Editor
The Santa Fe New Mexican
Santa Fe, New Mexico

Top honors in the Focused Editorials category of the Carmage Walls Commentary Prize competition were awarded to Inez Russell Gomez, opinion page editor of The Santa Fe New Mexican.

First-place includes a curved glass plaque and a cash prize of $3,000.

The editorials that were part of this entry focused on the Santa Fe Public School Board of Education’s need to make a choice between combining two local schools or rebuilding one for tens of millions of dollars despite low enrollment.

The editorials argued that combining the schools would make better use of existing facilities, avoid duplicating programs and expenses, and allow the district to invest its limited resources more effectively. The board’s decision followed community meetings and consideration of several alternatives, including rebuilding Martinez or moving students to other schools.

In submitting her entry, Gomez said: “We encouraged the district to merge two schools while also supporting the passage of a bond issue.” She said the bond issue passed and eventually, the board voted to keep one school shuttered and merge it with a second, similarly under-enrolled school.  

During the discussion, Gomez said there was a short-lived movement to put elementary students at a middle school.  “We opposed that as well,” she said, “and it did not happen.”

Patrick Dorsey, publisher of The Santa Fe New Mexican, said: “The citizens of Santa Fe and New Mexico demand lively and impactful Opinion Pages, and that is exactly what Inez consistently delivers for our audience and community.  She is in tune with all that makes our city and state so special and the many complex issues we face.  She uses her experience and deep knowledge of our very diverse community to craft impactful editorials and overall opinion pages daily.  These editorials on our local schools are a great example of her excellent work.”

Bill Church, executive editor, said: “The Santa Fe New Mexican’s award-winning Opinion pages are a result of independent ownership and an exceptional day-to-day editor in Inez Russell Gomez. She is the creator of thousands upon thousands of public-policy conversations that make a difference for all of New Mexico. She is a treasure.”

Three editorials were submitted as part of this entry:

Among the comments made by contest judges:

  • This entry combined editorial argument with substantial data and explained declining enrollment, elementary school mergers and closures in a way that would help readers — including those without children in the schools — understand the condition of a public school district they support through taxes.
  • These three editorials followed the issue effectively from start to finish.  At every point, it was clear what the newspaper believed was best for the community.  It made strong, convincing arguments and followed the issue through to completion.  It raised questions that needed to be addressed by the school board and by the broader community.  I thought it was extremely thorough and impactful. I enjoyed the writing, as well.  It was all the things you would want in an editorial.  
  • It was well-written and focused on an important topic that’s coming up in communities across the country.  I liked that it included a lot of data — strong, supporting points for its argument.  
  • The editorials were persuasive and there was a result at the end.

Read more about all contest winners